Step-by-Step Instructions
Mix the Garlic Butter:
In a small bowl combine softened butter with parmesan cheese Italian seasoning garlic powder and salt. Mix until smooth so the flavors meld well and the mixture spreads easily.
Assemble the Sandwiches:
Spread a thin even layer of pizza or marinara sauce on four slices of bread. Sprinkle each with shredded mozzarella then layer six pepperoni slices on top. Close each sandwich with a second slice of bread making sure the sauce is on the inside.
Butter the Outside:
Generously spread the prepared garlic butter over the outside of every sandwich ensuring full coverage for maximum crispness and flavor when grilled.
Grill the Sandwiches:
Heat a skillet over medium heat. Place sandwiches in the hot pan butter side down. Cook for three to four minutes per side pressing gently with a spatula until the bread is deep golden brown and the cheese is completely melted.
Serve and Enjoy:
Remove sandwiches from the pan. Let them cool for one to two minutes then slice and serve warm. Have extra marinara or pizza sauce ready for dipping just like at your favorite pizzeria.
A stack of three grilled cheese sandwiches.
Pin it
A stack of three grilled cheese sandwiches. | gracefulflavors.com
You Must Know
Vegetarian friendly without the pepperoni
Perfect for making ahead and enjoying later reheated
Great for lunch dinner or a hearty snack
I always look forward to using thick slices of rustic bread because it crisps beautifully and soaks up all the garlicky butter. Making this sandwich was a hit the afternoon we cooked together as a family everyone getting messy assembling their own with favorite toppings.
How to Store Leftovers
Keep any leftover sandwiches in an airtight container in the fridge. They will taste best if eaten within two days. To reheat place in a dry skillet over low heat until warmed through and crisp outside. Avoid microwaving as this can make the bread soggy.
Ingredient Swaps You Can Try
Feel free to use dairy-free cheese or make the sandwich fully vegetarian by skipping pepperoni and adding veggies like bell peppers spinach or sliced olives. For a whole grain twist try hearty whole wheat bread. You can even swap out the Italian seasoning for fresh basil or oregano if you have it on hand.
Serving Suggestions
Slice the sandwiches into strips for dipping at parties or pair with a crisp green salad for a balanced meal. These go amazingly well with tomato soup on chillier days. Sometimes I even cut them into bite-sized cubes for a fun twist on grilled cheese croutons in a Caesar salad.
A stack of three grilled cheese sandwiches with pepperoni.
Pin it
A stack of three grilled cheese sandwiches with pepperoni. | gracefulflavors.com
The Roots of Pizza Grilled Cheese
Pizza grilled cheese brings together two comfort food icons Italian-American pizza and classic grilled cheese. While the combination is not traditional Italian it reflects the American knack for playful adaptation. Each bite gives you the best of both worlds especially for anyone who grew up sharing pizza and grilled cheese in the same week.
Pro Tips
Always heat the skillet before adding your sandwiches for the best sizzle and crunch
Use freshly grated mozzarella cheese for optimal melt and stretch
Let sandwiches rest briefly before slicing to keep the cheese inside and prevent burning your fingers
Frequently Asked Questions
→ What bread works best for these sandwiches?
Sturdy options like sourdough or Italian bread hold up well and provide a crispy, satisfying texture without getting soggy.
→ Can I make these sandwiches vegetarian?
Yes, simply omit the pepperoni or use plant-based alternatives. These sandwiches are already rich in cheesy flavor and can be enjoyed without meat.
→ Which cheese melts best for this sandwich?
Mozzarella delivers a classic gooey texture, but you can mix in cheddar or provolone for a different flavor profile.
→ How do I prevent soggy sandwiches?
Spread sauce in a thin layer and use a hearty bread to keep everything crispy. Toast both sides until golden for best results.
→ What can I add for extra flavor or texture?
Try sliced mushrooms, olives, bell peppers, or a sprinkle of red pepper flakes for heat. Fresh basil adds a herbaceous kick.
→ Is this suitable for beginners?
Absolutely! Minimal prep, straightforward assembly, and easy skillet cooking make this ideal for cooks of all skill levels.
Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
Crispy bread, mozzarella, and pepperoni meet tangy sauce for the ultimate cheesy, melty sandwich delight.
